The mysterious pairs of planets we still can’t explain

The mysterious pairs of planets we still can’t explain

By Jonathan O’Callaghan
Nasa/Esa/CSA/Mark McCaughrean/Sam Pearson The Orion Nebula captured by the James Webb Space Telescope (Credit: Nasa/Esa/CSA/Mark McCaughrean/Sam Pearson)
Nasa/Esa/CSA/Mark McCaughrean/Sam Pearson (Credit: Nasa/Esa/CSA/Mark McCaughrean/Sam Pearson)

We thought we broadly understood how planets and stars form. But the discovery of dozens of pairs of young planets in a nearby nebula threatens to turn that on its head.

They are worlds that simply defy explanation. Drifting through the Orion Nebula – an enormous cloud of dust and gas relatively close by in our galaxy – are what appears to be dozens of Jupiter-sized planets that don’t conform to the conventional understanding of how planetary systems form. Rather than being bound to a star like the Earth is in our own Solar System, these planets are free-floating through space in pairs. Astronomers who spotted them with the help of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) could only scratch their heads in awe at the discovery.

“These things shouldn’t exist,” says Simon Portegies Zwart, an astrophysicist at Leiden University in the Netherlands. “They go against everything we have learned about star and planet formation.”

In the subsequent months, efforts have been made to try and explain what’s going on. These planets, called Jupiter Mass Binary Objects, or Jumbos, still cannot be fully explained. But we are getting closer to an answer – with crucial observations on the horizon that may solve the mystery once and for all.

Locus Forthcoming Books: JUNE

Locus Forthcoming Books: JUNE 2024 

  • CHAZ BRENCHLEY • Rowany De Vere • NewCon Press UK, Jun 2024 (tp, hc, eb)
  • TOBIAS S. BUCKELL & DAVID KLE¬CHA • The Runes of Engagements • Tachyon Publications, Jun 2024 (tp, eb)
  • M.R. CAREY • Echo of Worlds • Orbit US/Redhook, Jun 2024 (tp, eb)
  • VAJRA CHANDRASEKERA • Rakesfall • Tordotcom, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • LINDSAY ELLIS • Apostles of Mercy • Titan Books UK, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • LINDSAY ELLIS • Apostles of Mercy • St. Martin’s, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • JOANNE HARRIS • The Moonlight Market • Orion UK/Gollancz, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • KEVIN HEARNE • The Hermit Next Door • Subterranean Press, Jun 2024 (na, hc, eb)
  • ALLAN KASTER, ED. • The Year’s Top Hard Science Fiction Stories 8 • AudioText/Infinivox, Jun 2024 (an, tp, eb)
  • MERCEDES LACKEY & LARRY DIXON • Gryphon’s Valor • Titan Books UK, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • MERCEDES LACKEY & LARRY DIXON • Gryphon’s Valor • Astra House/DAW, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • SHARON LEE & STEVE MILLER • Ribbon Dance • Baen, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • YOON HA LEE • Moonstorm • Rebellion/Solaris UK, Jun 2024 (ya, tp, eb)
  • YOON HA LEE • Moonstorm • Penguin Random House/Delacorte, Jun 2024 (ya, hc, eb)
  • PREMEE MOHAMED • We Speak Through the Mountain • ECW Press, Jun 2024 (na, tp, eb)
  • TIM PRATT • The Knife and the Serpent • Angry Robot UK, Jun 2024 (tp, eb)
  • LILITH SAINTCROW • The Fall of Waterstone • Orbit UK, Jun 2024 (tp, eb)
  • LILITH SAINTCROW • The Fall of Waterstone • Orbit US, Jun 2024 (tp, eb)
  • JODI TAYLOR • Killing Time • Headline UK, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • ADRIAN TCHAIKOVSKY • Alien Clay • Orbit US/Redhook, Jun 2024 (1st US, hc, eb)
  • ADRIAN TCHAIKOVSKY • Service Model • Tordotcom, Jun 2024 (hc, eb)
  • PAUL TREMBLAY • Horror Movie • Titan Books UK, Jun 2024 (c, hc, eb)
  • PAUL TREMBLAY • Horror Movie • HarperCollins/Morrow, Jun 2024 (c, hc, eb)